Wool Fat Shaving Soap in Dish

Review of Multiple Related ProductsProducts Reviewed:• Merkur 34C HD double edger safety razor• Israeli Personna stainless steel double edge razor blades• Parker silvertip shaving brush• Simpson’s Wee Scot shaving brush• Simpson’s Classic 2 (best badger) shaving brush• Simpson’s Chubby 1 (super badger) shaving brush• Mitchell’s Wool Fat shaving soap• Tabac shaving soap in bowl• Tabac shaving stick• Proraso green shaving soap• Taylor of Old Bond Street Traditional shaving soap 57g travel size• Lucky Tiger aftershave and face tonicBackground:I switched to an electric razor approximately 35 years ago from a Gillette Atra razor and Edge shaving gel because I got tired of cutting myself. This led to a much less close shave but also saved me from cutting myself. Apparently in the pre-internet era, I had not properly learned how to shave. Being frustrated with the lack of close shave, I decided to give safety razor (“wet shaving”) another try. I am extremely glad that I did. I felt it was necessary to invest in quality but not the most expensive items to start. I began with the Merkur 34C razor, Israeli Personna (Personna Red) blades, the Parker silvertip brush and the Proraso shaving soap. The next step was to provide for a travel kit. This was accomplished with a cheap boar brush (not evaluated here) and Taylor of Old Bond Street Traditional shaving soap along with the Merkur razor. I next upgraded my travel kit to Simpson’s Wee Scot brush and Tabac shaving stick. My home supplies were upgraded to add the Simpson’s Classic 2 and Chubby 1 brushes, Mitchells Wool Fat shaving soap, Tabac shaving soap (after purchasing the stick), and the Lucky Tiger aftershave.Merkur 34C razor – I find this to be an excellent razor. It fits my hand well, gives great control with the short handle and provides for a clean comfortable close shave that is not too aggressive. The only criticism that I have is the finish is not as nice as certain other brands. When my luggage was temporarily lost, I purchased the same razor at the Art of Shaving for more than twice as much money, I did not feel it necessary to experiment with something else when this razor worked so well.Israeli Personna (Red) blades – These blades were purchased in a 100 pack at a very reasonable price. I chose them based on the overall reviews and have not been disappointed. I change the blade after four shaves and always get a consistently good shave.Parker silvertip shaving brush – This is a nice brush and a good value at its price point. It is soft on my skin and lathers Proraso very well. It does not have the backbone of the Simpson’s brushes and as such is now rarely used. I consider this a good starter brush if one is to limit their investment and give wet shaving a chance. With hindsight, I would have saved my money and gone right to the Simpson’s brushes if I were to do it over again. However, there is little to criticize for this brush at this price point.Simpson’s Wee Scot shaving brush – This brush is really small. It looks like a toy, but don’t be mistaken. It is surprisingly effective with the right soap and is excellent for travel. Be aware that even though this is a best badger brush, it is the scritchiest of all my brushes. Other reviewers have been able to get three passes from loading this brush once. I cannot, and therefore now load for each pass.Simpson’s Classic 2 shaving brush – This is a superior brush. This best badger brush is not nearly as scritchy as the Wee Scot. It has tremendous backbone and is superb for face lathering. The best badger hair is packed very densely which initially made it tough for the lather to release but with time the lather releases better. Be advised though that unless you live in a very dry climate, this is not an everyday brush as it takes more than 24 hours to dry and therefore must be rotated. Additionally, it will eat tremendous quantities of soap.Simpson’s Chubby 1 shaving brush (super badger) – This is my best brush. It is similar to the Classic 2 but even more dense with the super badger hair. The handle is slightly wider and bigger all around compared with the Classic 2. Both are good, but you need to like a short handle and be prepared to occasionally get lather on your fingers. Although this is a super badger brush, the degree of softness compared with the best badger Classic 2 is minimal. Compared with the Wee Scot, it is night and day. As with the Classic 2 this brush eats lather due to its density and also takes more than 24 hours to dry.Mitchell’s Wool Fat shaving soap – This is probably my favorite soap. It is however more difficult to lather. I have found that soaking the puck in tepid water while I shower has vastly improved its latherabilty. Tips for better lathering include not using very hot water, squeezing most of the water out of the brush and then adding only a few drops at a time when needed. The result is the best face feel after the shave of any of the soaps. It provides good cushioning and glide. The scent is minimal and not a factor at all for me.Tabac shaving soap – I first bought the stick for travel. Unfortunately the Amazon listing showed this as including the case. I only received the refill. Because the Wee Scot brush is so small, I tried lathering directly on the top of the refill stick and was completely satisfied with the results. So satisfied that I then bought the full size puck and bowl. I have since cut the stick into pieces and place it in the travel bowl with a screw down lid that came with the TOBS traditional soap and that is now my travel soap. This soap lather extremely well and is not so sensitive to the water level or have to be rehydrated as does the MWF. The scent is much stronger when lathering but eventually fades. I find the scent to be fine, I don’t have to have it, but don’t object to it at all. My wife likes this scent the best of all of my soaps. It provides good cushioning and glide and is extremely easy to lather. It does not have quite as good a feel after the shave as the MWF, but that is more a statement of how good the MWF is. I do however rotate daily between this and the MWF. They are both that good.Proraso green shaving soap – I started with this soap and found it good, but nowhere near as good as the MWF or Tabac. It lathers well and is probably the least expensive of any of the soaps that I have used. It provides decent cushioning and glide, but my face feels dryer after shaving than with the MWF and the Tabac.Taylor of Old Bond Street (“TOBS”) Traditional shaving soap – I was very dissatisfied with this soap. It did not lather with the cheap boar brush, and then I found it did not lather well with any of my other brushes. It did not provide good cushioning or glide and I got the least close shaves with this soap than any other. Given that I can lather MWF, I tend to think it is more the soap than I am the problem. I popped the puck out of the plastic travel case and filled the case with the Tabac stick for my travel needs. The soap was used a bathroom hand soap, because the price was just too high to throw away largely unused.Lucky Tiger aftershave and face balm – I like this aftershave which is largely witch hazel based with a host of other natural ingredients. There is no alcohol in this product so it does not have the burning bracing effect that some like. It has an orangey citrus scent that goes away after about 30 seconds. This aftershave is very thin and absorbs well. It moisturizes (especially with the MWF) and is a product that feels very clean to me.Other comments:After reading comments from others, I have learned that pill bottles that can be obtained for free from most pharmacies make excellent travel cases for brushes. I drill several holes in the cap for ventilation. I have also used a pill bottle to store the Tabac refill pieces not put in the travel bowl

Mitchell's Wool Fat is a controversial product, at least controversial by wet shaving gear standards. On the forums, most people either love or hate MWF. I had to try it for myself to decide....and the results weren't good. Up front, let me just say that my favorite soaps/creams are Tabac, Proraso Green, Castle Forbes Lime, and Oglalla Bay Rum. I would use the lather that those products produce as my standard for what is excellent. I'm looking for thick and slick lather with a yogurt-like viscosity that cushions and lubricates the blade as it reduces stubble.The Pros of MWF: I really like the scent of MWF. It's clean and classic. It has a very masculine soapy scent that lasts, but isn't over-powering. Also, I like the ceramic container. It works wells and looks classy.The Cons of MWF: For me, I simply could not get a shave-worthy lather. I tried hot, warm, and cool water. I tried distilled water and tap water. I tried a boar brush and a badger brush. I tried a wet brush, a damp brush, and a dry brush. I tried loading the brush for over a minute. I tried face-lathering and bowl lathering. The results were consistently airy, bubbly, foamy lather that didn't work. I got the worse razor burn of my life using MWF. My neck looked like hamburger after a three pass shave. I ended up selling MWF on a forum because (for me) it just wasn't worth all the effort. There are just too many other products out there that produce vastly superior lather with significantly less work than MWF, so while the scent is nice and the bowl looks classy, I won't bother with The Fat again.You may have to try it for yourself (and I would encourage each person to give MWF a fair shake) but just know the risks.***UPDATE ON MAY 20, 2014***Okay, okay I take it all back. After several months of working MWF into my rotation, I've finally figured out how to get a proper lather from this behemoth of a soap. You just have to resist the urge to add water except for little bits at a time as you work the lather. That's the key, I believe. And you have to know that the lather won't look like Tabac or Proraso. It will be less dense, but will perform toe-to-toe with any product on the market. The real difference with MWF is 4-5 hours after your shave. Your face is still BBS with no signs of five o'clock shadow. That must be the lanolin, I guess. After quite a bit of work, MWF is now a product that I'll never be without in my shave den.

To date this has been by far the best shave soap I have ever used. Many months later after purchasing it, I still have more than half of the puck left and don't expect I will even come close to finishing the entire thing after an entire calendar year (I shave 3 times a week). I use a cheap Omega Boar Brush for this and a "mug" i have dedicated as a shaving mug to produce a lather. The lather is strong with this one.Its also a very moisturizing soap which is doing wonder for me as winter is coming around. I highly recommend.