Maybelline Unstoppable Waterproof Mechanical Black Eyeliner Pencil, Easy to Apply, Smooth Glide, Up to 24 Hour Wear, Onyx

Have purchased multiple times; use it everyday.

Love this eye liner, doesn't irritate my eyes and no smudge. Great price for 2.

I love this eye liner. It's soft enough that it goes on without pulling and it stays put all day long. I love this color. It's a bit brighter and lighter than the typical brown eye liners. Very good value for the money.

Love these pencils. But one out of the two , head was broke all the way down. That happened before. Hassle to send back , if it happens once more, I will send back . The are nice pencils. The texture glides nicely

Just the right amount of softness to apply along the eyelash line without trauma to eyelid. I use one shade lighter than my eyelash color to avoid looking like a street performer. A lighter line looks more natural. Was pleased with how long the line was maintained, but did require makeup remover to remove residual after soap and water washing. Not having to sharpen it was a plus. Cannot yet comment on longevity.

I used this brand & shade as a lip liner. It is my all time favorite and it lasts long. I have this on auto ship because they can't keep it stocked at my local Walgreens.

This is this best brand by far. Most other brands make my eyes water.

I’ve been trying to find an eyeliner that won’t smudge throughout my work day & was hoping this one wouldn’t but… it does.